Monday, June 17, 2013

Methodist Week: Chicken with Broccoli Casserole

I grew up in a Baptist school and Presbyterian and Methodist churches.  If there's one thing I know about these places, it's that when you have a potluck or some kind of get-together involving food, the dishes are always A+.  Southern church ladies always know how to make a good potluck dish.

I collect church cookbooks.  I have a collection right now of. . .probably 40 or 50 of them.  They were in abundance at the book sale, and I really enjoy going through them and seeing the similarities and differences between the dishes and seeing a little insight into the people of a particular church.

Last year, for her birthday, my sister Katie requested a Chocolate Chess Pie in lieu of a cake.  I'd never in my life made a chocolate chess pie.  I didn't even know what was in a chocolate chess pie.  But I said, "You know, if anyone will know how to make it, it'll be a Methodist lady."

So I pulled a Methodist church cookbook off my shelf and, lo and behold, there was a Chocolate Chess Pie recipe.

Long-ish story short, this week is Methodist Week.  I took 5 recipes from 5 Methodist cookbooks and made them all.  It was like a week-long potluck.

The first book hails from Kipling United Methodist Church in Kipling, NC.  It seems they celebrated their 150-year anniversary last year, and that's pretty cool.

The recipe itself is from Howard and Gladys Robbins, and I Googled both of them, but could find out if they were still at the church, or still in the area, or anything like that. 

This is not an act of terrorism. The book fell apart when I opened it, and I forgot to take a picture of it intact.

Dennis especially loved this recipe.  He said it reminded him of his grandmother's house.  It was really, really good for being so simple.

My favorite thing about these recipes is how vague the amounts and directions are.  A "package" of chicken. "Some" carrots.  It's a different method of measurement, for sure.

Let Methodist Week commence!

Chicken with Broccoli Casserole

Serves 3-4

Here's the original recipe:


My version

3 large chicken breasts ("1 package"), chopped into several pieces
2 cups fresh broccoli
1 can cream of chicken soup (I can't stand cream of mushroom.  Use whichever you want, though.)
6 oz. shredded cheddar cheese (There are 8 oz. in the photo above.  I'll explain later.)
Olive oil for cooking chicken

Preheat oven to 350°F.

Cook chicken until done (until it's no longer pink in the middle: at least 165°F).  Cook the broccoli.  (I'll admit straight up that I don't officially know how to cook broccoli.  I bring salted water to a boil and cook broccoli for about 5 minutes, until broccoli turns bright green.)

Put broccoli in 9 x 13" baking dish, followed by chicken, then soup.  Cover with cheese.

(I had 8 oz. cheese ready for this recipe, but I started putting it in the dish, and it just seemed like. . .a lot of cheese.  So I didn't use all of it.  I know.  You're shocked.)

Bake the casserole for 20 minutes.  Remove from oven, make a delicious salad, and enjoy.  It's really, really good!


  1. Stopping by from Tasty Tuesdays to show some love! Your cheesy chickeny goodness sounds delish!!

  2. Sarah, you're so funny! :) Are you sure that wasn't book terrorism? Ha! I am adding this to my July menu and making it next month! :) It sounds perfect for a weeknight. I love and hate those vague measurements, especially when there's no photo! Thank you so much for linking up with me this week at Tasty Tuesdays! I’ve pinned this & shared it with my followers! Please be sure to stop back by the party and check out some of the other links!

  3. This looks great! I am already a huge fan of broccoli & cheese - but then there is cream of mushroom and chicken added and I am ready for a plate right now. :) Pinning to make very soon!

    Thanks for linking up to Tasty Tuesdays - hope to see you again this week!